RSS/XML | Add to My Yahoo!| Essays | Main Page | Disclaimer | |

October 5, 2005

Netherlands legalizes killing babies

by

Years ago the Netherlands legalized euthanasia of terminally-ill patients. The law makes it permissible for medical doctors to adminster lethal doses of certain drugs to the patients when the patient requests it. At first, the law was restricted in applicability to adult patient, then was expanded to include children.

Now babies may be killed by their doctors. Note well, not allowed to die on their own through withdrawal of life-sustaining care. but actually killed.

AMSTERDAM — The Netherlands is expanding its controversial euthanasia policy with guidelines on when doctors may end the lives of ill infants with the parents’ consent.

A draft of the new regulations will be presented to the Dutch parliament for debate in October. However the expansion of the policy will not require a change of the law, a spokesperson for the Ministry of Health told news agency AP on Thursday.

The move follows controversial cases in which doctors ended the lives of terminally-ill children.

The change could also set a precedent for how doctors handle other cases in which patients are unable to give informed consent due to learning disability or dementia.

The Netherlands became the first nation to legalise euthanasia for adults under some conditions in 2001.

But doctors had been killing their patients for many years before 2001 without penalty by Dutch law. A woman named Hilly Boscher was killed by a psychiatrist in 1991 because she felt incapable of coping with the deaths of her two children, one from disease and one from suicide. He inetrviewed Ms. Boscher four time over five weeks and then “euthanized” her.

Rather than punish the psychiatrist for facilitating the death instead of trying to save the life of his suicidal patient, the Dutch Supreme Court essentially applauded his actions, ruling that there is no difference between physical and emotional suffering when justifying euthanasia.

As Wesley Smith pointed out in 2003,

supposedly ironclad protections against abuse — such as the doctrine of force mejeur and the stipulation that patient give multiple requests for euthanasia — quickly ceased meaningfully to constrain mercy killing. As a consequence, Dutch doctors now legally kill terminally ill people who ask for it, chronically ill people who ask for it, disabled people who ask for it, and depressed people who ask for it.

But killing babies is no new thing. Today’s news just makes formal what has been going on for many years.

According to a 1997 study published in the British medical journal The Lancet, approximately 8 percent of all Dutch infant deaths result from lethal injections. The babies deemed killable are often disabled and thus are thought not to have a “livable life.” The practice has become so common that 45 percent of neonatologists and 31 percent of pediatricians who responded to Lancet surveys had killed babies.

The summary of the study on The Lancet’s site says,

In the death-certificate study, 57% of all deaths had been preceded by a decision [by the parents and doctor] to forgo life-sustaining treatment; this decision was accompanied by the administration of potentially life-shortening drugs to alleviate pain or other symptoms in 23%, and by the administration of drugs with the explicit aim of hastening death in 8%. A drug was given explicitly to hasten death to neonates not dependent on life-sustaining treatment in 1% of all death cases. No chance of survival was the main motive in 76% of all end-of-life decisions, and a poor prognosis was the main motive in 18%. The interview study showed that parents had been involved in making 79% of decisions. The physicians consulted colleagues about 88% of decisions. Most paediatricians favoured formal review of medical decisions by colleagues together with ethical or legal experts.

The slippery slope is well greased.

Relatedly, Oregon’s law permitting physician-assisted suicide is now before the Supreme Court.


Posted @ 12:27 pm. Filed under Culture, Foreign Affairs, Europe & NATO, Law & Politics, Foreign


Comments policy



Commenting is provided as a courtesy only. I review all comments before they appear. I do not edit comments, I I only approve or delete. My criteria for approving or deleting generally correspond to the following guidelines but in the end are subjective.

Comments using profanity automatically get tossed into the bit bucket - I never see them and neither does anyone else.

No personal attacks, name calling or commercial commenting. Links to your own blog site or relevant other web pages are fine.

Please be brief and relevant to the post.

I rarely answer comments, I just don't have the time.

6 Responses to “Netherlands legalizes killing babies”

  1. corrie Says:

    Molech must be pleased.

  2. Dr Bob Says:

    The practice of infant euthanasia has been around for a while in the Netherlands-it received some attention last year regarding the Groningen protocol. The current legislation just formally legalizes and existing practice.

    Here’s a post I wrote on this topic last December:

    The Doctor Is In » The Children Whom Reason Scorns

  3. The Unalienable Right » Oregon is to die for Says:

    […] 221; More from Ann Althouse. Also linked on OTB’s Traffic Jam. Related news from Donald Sensing. It seems obvious we should be very caref […]

  4. Richard Heddleson Says:

    I can’t give the link, but I recall another survey of Dutch doctors that indicated large numbers of them had killed patients they saw as hopeless without discussion with the patient or family. Assisted suicide is coming. And having watched how modern medical science can prolong life until bank accounts are empty and survivors poor, I’m not prepared to condemn those who make that choice. And abortion is not going away, at least in the blue states. But the medical profession would be well advised to cleave to the Hippocratic oath and have the law assign another profession the responsibility to do the executions, elective abortions and euthanasias. Otherwise, one will never know what the interests of the physician, who is being paid by an insurance company, really are.

  5. Nancy Reyes Says:

    Given today’s editorial by David Brooks, who like Plato laments how modern medicine keeps people alive, we will have more and more of the same…check out the International Anti Euthanasia website…http://www.iaetf.org/

  6. CaNN :: We started it. Says:

    […] AF DEATH-CULT ; Bishop “deeply worried” about Euthanasia Bill …. (CW, Lifesite) NAZISM WINS: Netherlands legalizes killing babies; Essay […]

Leave a Reply



Email is considered publishable unless you request otherwise. Sorry, I cannot promise a reply.

Archives

October 2005
S M T W T F S
« Sep   Nov »
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031  

Archives for Jan 03-Mar 05.

Blogroll:

News sites:

Washington Times
Washington Post
National Review
Drudge Report
National Post
Real Clear Politics
NewsMax
New York Times
UK Times
Economist
Jerusalem Post
The Nation (Pakistan)
World Press Review
Fox News
CNN
BBC
USA Today
Omaha World Herald
News Is Free
Rocky Mtn. News
Gettys Images
Iraq Today

Opinions, Current Events and References

Opinion Journal
US Central Command
BlogRunner 100
The Strategy Page
Reason Online
City Journal
Lewis & Clark links
Front Page
Independent Women's Forum
Jewish World Review
Foreign Policy in Focus
Policy Review
The New Criterion
Joyner Library Links
National Interest
Middle East Media Research Institute
Institute for the Secularisation of Islamic Society
Sojourners Online
Brethren Revival
Saddam Hussein's Iraq
National Coalition Against Legalized Gambling
Telford Work
Unbound Bible
Good News Movement
UM Accountability
Institute for Religion and Democracy
Liberty Magazine

Useful Sites:

Internet Movie Database
Mapquest
JunkScience.com
Webster Dictionary
U.S. Army Site
Defense Dept.
Iraq Net
WMD Handbook Urban Legends (Snopes)
Auto Consumer Guide
CIA World Fact Book
Blogging tools
Map library
Online Speech Bank
Technorati
(My Tech. page)

Shooting Sports

Trapshooting Assn.
Nat. Skeet Shooting Assn.
Trapshooters.com
Clay-Shooting.com
NRA
Baikal
Beretta USA
Browning
Benelli USA
Charles Daly
Colt
CZ USA
EAA
H-K; FABARM USA
Fausti Stefano
Franchi USA
Kimber America
Remington
Rizzini
Ruger
Tristar
Verona
Weatherby
Winchester
Blogwise
Excellent essays by other writers of enduring interest

Coffee Links

How to roast your own coffee!

I buy from Delaware City Coffee Company
CoffeeMaria
Gillies Coffees
Bald Mountain
Front Porch Coffee
Burman Coffee
Café Maison
CCM Coffee
Coffee Bean Corral
Coffee Bean Co.
Coffee for Less
Coffee Links Page
Coffee Storehouse
Coffee, Tea, Etc.
Batian Peak
Coffee & Kitchen
Coffee Project
HealthCrafts Coffee
MollyCoffee
NM Piñon Coffee
Coffee is My Drug of Choice
Pony Espresso
Pro Coffee
7 Bridges Co-op
Story House
Sweet Maria’s
Two Loons
Kona Mountain
The Coffee Web
Zach and Dani’s

Roast profile chart

Links for me

Verizon text msg
HTML special codes
Google Maps
Comcast
RhymeZone
Bin Laden's Strategic Plan
Online Radio
The Big Picture
SSM essay index
See my Essays Index!
Web Enalysis

categories:

Other:

Internal links:

An online news and commentary magazine by Donald Sensing, concentrating on foreign and military policy and religious matters. My bio is here.

Google Search
WWW
This site
Old Blogspot OHC

Fresh Content.net

Sitemeter

Fight Spam! Click Here!

16 queries. 0.593 seconds